Results
Every page I built, measured twice.
In May 2026 I built 1,004 location pages on three contractor sites, working behind the agency that managed them. I checked each page against the search it was built for on August 9 and again on November 7. Both runs are below: which pages Google dropped, what it showed in their place, and what I can and can't say about why.
Aug 9, 2026 counted to the top 30
Nov 7, 2026 top 30
The same 1,004 searches went out both times. 13 of the August checks returned no data, which is why the August count is lower.
- In the top 3
- Matched, lower down
- Another page from the site
- Not found
| Client | Aug 9, 2026 top 3 | Nov 7, 2026 top 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Precision Patch Pros Drywall repair 448 of 512 pages merged between the checks | 144 | 13 |
| L'Artisan du Plancher Flooring and stairs, French and English | 89 | 10 |
| RPM Septic Systems Septic services | 5 | 0 |
| All three sites | 238 | 23 |
August 9, 2026: live Google results, top 100, desktop, not personalised, country level (US for the US sites, Canada for Quebec), organic results only. November 7, 2026: the same searches, top 30, desktop, country level, organic results only.
What held
The pages that held were built around real work.
On November 7, where a generated page had dropped but the client's site was still in the top 30, Google showed one of these instead. That happened in 214 searches.
The client's own service and area pages
140 searches. The main service pages, region pages and the few town pages each client had outside my build.
Write-ups of single finished jobs
20 searches, 5 of them in the top 3, across 15 different job pages. L'Artisan du Plancher was the only site with a portfolio of jobs, so they all come from there. Three of them, so you can open them yourself:
- lartisanduplancher.com/en/portfolio/renovation-of-a-parquet-floor-staircase-and-hardwood-railing-in-terrebonne/ #2 on Nov 7
- lartisanduplancher.com/fr/portfolio/sablage-de-plancher-a-outremont-preservation-du-patrimoine-de-la-rampe-descalier-et-dun-escalier-centenaire-fabrique-a-la-main/ #2 on Nov 7
- lartisanduplancher.com/en/portfolio/floor-repair-and-finishing-in-montreal-west/ #2 on Nov 7
The home page or a list page
24 searches: the client's home page, or a portfolio or category index.
Another generated page
30 searches, where a sibling page for a different service or town came up instead.
The pages that held are the clients' own. The counts show which kind of page held through the same updates, not how much traffic it gets.
Why they dropped
Most likely, Google's 2026 spam updates.
The updates ran August 18 to 21 and September 24 to October 8, both between my two checks. Google's spam policy describes doorway abuse with examples including "pages targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page" and "substantially similar pages that are closer to search results than a clearly defined, browseable hierarchy". A grid of one page per service per town sits close to both.
Of the 238 searches that had the page in the top 3 in August, 12 still had it in the top 30 on November 7, 39 showed a different page from the client's site, and 187 showed none. Pages spot-checked from that last group still load but are no longer in Google's index. Without Search Console access for these sites, the cause stays most likely rather than confirmed.
Put the two runs together and the pattern holds on all three sites. The pages Google dropped were the ones generated from a list of searches. The pages it kept showing were the clients' own: their services, their areas and, where they had them, their finished jobs. So that's the only kind of page I build now. Each one starts from a real completed job, I fact-check it before it goes live, and I measure it before launch and every month.
Reading the counts
How to read the numbers.
One client merged most of its pages
Between the two checks, Precision Patch Pros merged seven of its eight drywall service lines into one "drywall repair [town]" page per town, so 448 of its 512 URLs now redirect. For those searches, November counts the town page when Google returned it. The other two sites merged nothing. Their top 3 count went from 94 to 10, against 144 to 13 on the drywall site, so the merge doesn't explain the drop.
Both dates are counted at the top 30
August read the top 100 results for each search and November the top 30. Of the 308 pages found in August, 307 were already in the top 30, so every count here uses the top 30 for both dates. The client pages still show the August position of the one page below that.
Matched
For each page I searched Google for the exact phrase it was built for, like "septic excavation Oxford". If the page built for that search was the client result Google returned, it counts as matched, at whatever position it held. On the drywall site in November, the town page that replaced a merged page also counts.
Another page came up instead
On August 9, a different page from the client's site came up instead in 549 of the 991 searches, often a sibling from the same build. By November 7 the count was 215. Those don't count as matches. The August data for the drywall site kept only the first client page per search, so its August figures are floors.
Median
The median covers matched pages only: #2 in August and #2 in November. It tells you that pages which still show up tend to show near the top, and nothing about the ones that stopped showing up.
Drywall repair
Precision Patch Pros
Drywall repair across 64 towns in Southern California. The largest build, and the one the client merged between the two checks.
144 in the top 3 on Aug 9, 2026 13 on Nov 7, 2026
Every page on both datesFlooring and stairs
L'Artisan du Plancher
Flooring and stairs in Quebec, built twice: once in French, once in English. Nothing was merged, so both dates measure the same pages.
89 in the top 3 on Aug 9, 2026 10 on Nov 7, 2026
Every page on both datesSeptic services
RPM Septic Systems
Septic services across 20 towns in Connecticut, where the homepage outranked the town pages.
5 in the top 3 on Aug 9, 2026 0 on Nov 7, 2026
Every page on both datesSend me one client's website.
I'll check which of its location pages Google still shows and send you a short summary.